Insurance comparison website

Confused.com homepage redesign to improve conversions

structured A/B testing and iterative UX design

User journeys Product design A/B Testing UX
Confused.com Quote Process

My role

As the lead designer, I maintained and refined the style guide, ensured consistent branding, redeveloped the quote process, and supported marketing campaigns and digital initiatives for the website and social channels.

  • Led homepage redesign and branding during company rebrand
  • Produced web marketing banners and social media content


The UX challenge

Redesigning the Confused.com homepage required balancing multiple stakeholder priorities, iterative user testing, and careful A/B testing to optimise the conversion funnel without negatively impacting revenue. The project spanned nine months of design, testing, and optimisation.

Confused.com homepage redesign by Interaction Designer Martin Gray

User research & discovery

  • Stakeholder workshops to align business goals
  • Regular Customer Q&A research sessions (Meet the Customer)
  • Card sorting to prioritise homepage content
  • Behavioural feedback on quote journey friction points

The approach

Initial concepts were sketched on post-it notes, refined via card sorting, and iteratively prototyped in Balsamiq before coding in HTML. Live A/B tests were run incrementally (1% → 100% of traffic) to measure improvements in click-through and quote completion rates.

“Meet the Customer” sessions provided crucial user feedback, guiding content hierarchy, visual clarity, and interaction flow.

Results

  • +2% increase in click-through rate to car insurance quote
  • +4% uplift in conversion through quote journey optimisation
  • Improved homepage engagement through iterative A/B testing

Click here to view the final build:

Confused.com homepage A/B testing and redesign by Interaction designer Martin Gray


A/B Testing & Conversion Optimisation

Multiple homepage variations were tested against the original, measuring click-through, quote completion, and engagement depth. Incremental traffic allocation ensured safe, data-driven improvements.

FAQ

What UX methods were used?

User research, card sorting, iterative wireframing, and live A/B testing.

What impact did the redesign have?

Improved click-through by 2% and quote journey conversions by 4%, resulting in significant revenue increase.

Confused.com home contents insurance page redesign - Martin Gray portfolio Confused.com quote process journey and redesign - Martin Gray portfolio Confused.com prices page redesign - Martin Gray portfolio